Transferring of 78 RPM and LP's -
78 RPM and RIAA Preamp
Equipment List and Pro-audio
links - References
Price list - Danish
Homepage - Search vadlyd.dk
|
(not in stock now)
VADLYD MD12 MK4 includes as standard vertical/lateral switch, and switchable inputs for MM/MC cartridges. MC inputs are with 3 switchable load impedances: 50, 100, and 200 ohms.
Recording engineers and serious record
collectors know the problem when playing early phonograph records:
ordinary RIAA phono equalization does not always match the original
recording equalization that was used to make the record.
78rpm records in particular have many different eq settings depending on period, placement, and recording company. Even within the same company, there may be differences depending on which engineer was on job that day.
Overview:
A few words concerning long life of all electronic equipment: most
potentiometers can stand severe wear for decades, but dust - and
especially smoke - can make them noisy in a very short time. Tobacco
smoke is ALMOST as dangerous for a pot as it is for your health!
When playing phonograph records, you might normally use the phono
input provided on your amplifier, often called a RIAA (Recording
Industries Association in America) phono input.
The RIAA equalization curve specifies two turnover points (a
turnover point is where the level changes ±3dB): one at 500Hz, and
the other at 2125Hz. The RIAA playback curve has the following
theoretical response:
1. +17dB from 20Hz to 50Hz, then falling about 6dB/octave to
2. 0dB from 500Hz to 2125Hz, and then falling again about 6dB/octave
to
3. -13.7dB at 10kHz.
You use the RIAA playback curve to compensate for the RIAA
equalization that was originally used to make the record.
Normally this works well on single, EP and LP records, issued from
1955 and later. But with earlier LPs (some record companies didnt
use RIAA before 1960), this curve is not correct. The cutting
equalizations on all 78 RPMs and LPs before 1955 have been very
different. 78rpm records in particular used curves very different
from the RIAA curve. For this reason, you should not use the RIAA
phono input on your amplifier if you want good quality reproduction
of 78rpm records.
I want to thank Roger Wilmut for basic information about
reproduction of 78rpm records. For a better understanding of the
problems of reproduction of records, read the following articles
(with a few edits from my hand) taken with kind permission from
Roger Wilmuts home page: ”Reproduction of 78rpm records” -
www.rfwilmut.clara.net/repro78/repro.html.
EQUALIZATION OF PHONOGRAPH RECORDS
The simplest form of disk cutter consists of an amplifier, similar
to that used to drive a loudspeaker, connected to a cutting head
having a stylus connected to a coil, which is placed in the field
from a strong magnet (or, more usually in later designs, a magnet
within a coil). When the signal is applied to the coil, the stylus
moves and engraves a groove in the blank disk. (There is of course a
lot more to it than that, but we are considering only the basics
here.)
However, because the cutter heads movements translate the amplitude
swings of the original signal into velocity - the rate at which the
stylus moves during its swings - low-frequency signals would be
recorded with a much larger swing than high-frequency signals of the
same original amplitude. In order to keep the movements of the
groove much the same at all frequencies (given equal level signals)
it is necessary to use a circuit to introduce - in the theoretical
situation - a 6 dB/octave cut as the frequency decreases - i.e.,
halve the frequency and you halve the voltage.
In the reverse situation, that of a reproduction head, the principal
is that of a wire moved in a magnetic field - it is the rate of
cutting lines of force that matters. The cutter head works exactly
in reverse, like a simple motor, where increased voltage means
increased speed. Therefore, the constant amplitude groove
theoretically achieved produces a signal where the bass is low and
the treble high: so a 6 dB/octave cut with increasing frequency
would be called for.
In the real world, losses in the head with increased frequency
complicate the issue. Early cutter heads were highly inefficient,
and so, while the bass cut described above was used, the treble
trailed away, resulting in equal groove modulations (movements) up
to mid frequencies, but decreasing above that.
To compensate for this, the playback characteristic boosted the bass
below 200 Hz but left it flat above that - effectively providing a 6
dB/octave boost to the higher frequencies (and the surface noise).
With the later improvements in cutters, it was possible to pack more
treble onto the records, and so new equalizations provided for a 6
dB/octave cut above a turnover frequency which varied between 3.4
and about 6 kHz, depending on the system.
Similar techniques were applied to microgroove records, and the
final standard, RIAA, provides for a bass boost below 500 Hz and a
treble cut above the lower frequency of 2,212 kHz - the latter
reflecting the considerably increased amount of treble which can be
cut onto an LP.
Therefore playing a 78rpm record using RIAA equalization - all that
is available to many people - produces far less top end response
than is correct, particularly for the earliest electrical records,
where the result is akin to turning the treble control down.
(Turning the treble up gives an improvement, but it doesnt touch the
important mid-range.)
Use of the correct eq curves when reproducing 78rpm records produces
a startling improvement in the sound quality (although admittedly
the surface noise can increase).
Many of these older recordings are of surprisingly high quality
after all!
At the time the format disappeared as a popular format, the
recommended stylus size was 60 (0.0025”) conical tip. This would be
satisfactory for records made in the final few years, but for the
great majority of the time since the beginning of 78s in 1896 the
grooves were much wider than the standard, with the result that a 60
stylus skates about in the bottom of the groove, seriously
increasing the surface noise.
The basic stylus is conical, with a spherical tip; the included
angle of the cone is 60 degrees. Most modern styli are elliptical:
i.e. they look the same from the front, but from the side they have
a much narrower angle. This enables them to track movements in the
groove more easily (as the groove moves from side to side it
effectively narrows - not across its direct width but across the
diameter of the conical tip, at an angle to the direction of travel:
consequently a spherical tip will ride up in the groove).
The illustrations below could apply equally to a spherical tip and
an elliptical tip seen from the front: in practice I would always
recommend elliptical.
![]() |
A modern record groove should be a neat 90 degrees, with the stylus making contact at only two points part-way up the groove wall, thus avoiding any debris in the bottom of the groove. (Some modern microgroove styli have a flat section at the contact point, giving a wider area of contact which reduces wear: however it can also increase noise from worn or damaged groove walls and I would be dubious about its use for 78s). |
However older 78s were cut to be used with steel needles, on the assumption that the needle would wear down to fit the groove in the first few seconds: when this wider groove is tracked with a 2.5 thou stylus the result is ‘bottoming’ as can be seen here. |
![]() |
![]()
|
Here the combination of a larger basic size: 70µ (0.0028”) works on the majority of records, although larger sizes may be helpful with very old records - and the truncated tip (which is spherical down to the contact points but truncated below) result in vastly better tracking. Like LPs, Records in good condition, will be better reproduced If the stylus is elliptical. This brings a considerable improvement in distortion and will be with reduced surface noise and greater analysis. With records in poor condition, you often will have a better reproduction with conical styli. |
Records from |
Conical truncated |
Eliptical truncated |
Before 1920: |
100µ (0.0040") |
100µ x 30µ (0.0040" x 0.0012") |
1920 - 1939: |
90µ (0.0035") |
90µ x 30µ (0.0035" x 0.0012") |
1939 - : |
70µ (0.0028") |
70µ x 25µ (0.0028" x 0.0009") |
P.O. Box 3 - Ashtead
Surrey KT21 "QD - England
Tel: +44 01372 276604
Not all 78s were actually recorded at 78 rpm. Even in the late
1920s, English Columbia was still using 80 rpm, and prior to about
1921 speeds were widely variable. Speeds as low as 68 or as high as
84 rpm are not uncommon.
To make matters worse, relatively few 78rpm records state the speed
(and when they do its not always accurate). If the work is a
classical piece such as an opera aria, it is possible to check the
correct pitch against a score or a modern recording. However, as
occasionally singers would transpose, even this isn't completely
reliable. My best recommendation is to gradually reduce the speed of
a record until it starts to sound sluggish, and then increase it
slightly (in my experience the ear is much more sensitive to low
speeds than high speeds).
Finding a turntable capable of coping with these speeds is often a
challenge. I dont know of any normally available turntable which has
more than a tiny variation (usually 2 or 3 %), which is nowhere near
enough); but electronically controlled turntables may be modifiable.
You need a speed range of 72 to 82 to cover most records.
For further information, see Roger Wilmuts web site:
http://www.rfwilmut.clara.net/repro78/repro.html. This site contains
additional information about 78rpm records.
Coarse Groove (78 rpm)
SYSTEM |
Treble turnover |
Bass turnover |
Lower bass t/o |
Cut at 10 kHz |
Boost at 50 hz |
Flat |
flat |
flat |
|
|
|
US MID 30 |
flat |
400 Hz |
70 Hz |
- |
16 dB |
WESTREX |
flat |
200 Hz |
- |
- |
15 dB |
HMV |
flat |
250 Hz |
50 Hz |
- |
12 dB |
ffrr 1949 |
6.36 kHz |
250 Hz |
40 Hz |
5 dB |
12 dB |
Early DECCA |
5.8 kHz |
150 Hz |
- |
6 dB |
11 dB |
Columbia |
1.6 kHz |
300 Hz |
- |
16 dB |
14 dB |
BSI |
3.18 kHz |
353 Hz |
50 Hz |
10.5 dB |
14 dB |
Note that record companies used many different eq settings, and
sometimes the same company used different settings depending on
which recording engineer was on job.
Generally, there is a difference between American and European
78 rpm recordings: the American records were normally much
louder cut with much more bass response and a higher bass
turnover frequency. The two American record companies Columbia
and Victor had different settings but both used basically the
patent from Western Electric.
Since theory and practice are not always the same, always use
your ears! This is especially true with records in bad
condition, which as a result of wear have often lost much their
high frequency response. Unfortunately, many 78s are in bad
condition because they have been played many times.
Ideally, use FLAT for old acoustic recordings. Sometimes you
will find that you will get a better sound with a little bass
lift. Then try one of the other eq settings and use the 80 Hz
bass cut filter.
Next eq is US MID 30, which is useful for a lot of American
records. Normally you should use it together with the variable
low pass filter and find the right settings. Good for American
Victor.
Use WESTREX (English Western Electric) for HMV 78s with a
triangle matrix code and English Columbias with a “W” Matrix
code.
HMV eq is used for HMVs with a square matrix code, and English
Columbia with a “C” matrix code, or in both cases with no code
(post 1945 up to about 1953).
ffrr 1949 is used by Decca and EMI.
Early Decca are Decca eq setting from 30s.
Columbia is an American Columbia setting used by Columbia since
around 1930. But note: this setting is an ideal setting and only
useful for records in absolute good condition
.
BSI 78 useful for all post 1953 78s. It can also be useful for
some earlier American 78s.
SYSTEM |
Treble turnover |
Bass turnover |
Lower bass t/o |
Cut at 10 kHz |
Boost at 50 hz |
ffrr LP 1953 |
3 kHz |
450 Hz |
100 Hz |
11 dB |
12.5 dB |
CCIR |
3.18 kHz |
500 Hz |
50 Hz |
10.5 dB |
17 dB |
NAB |
1.6 kHz |
500 Hz |
- |
16 dB |
16 dB |
RIAA | 2.1215 kHz | 500.5 Hz | 50.5 Hz | 13.6 dB | 17 dB |
CCIR is used by European labels for early LPs and EPs
.
Use NAB (NARTB) for some early American LPs. Use NAB together
with the first order 80 Hz bass cut filter for American Columbia
LPs.
RIAA is the universal standard (in theory) of all EP/LPs after
1955
.
REPRODUCTION OF PATHÉ AND EDISON VERTICAL CUT RECORDS
Normally mono recordings are lateral, which means ”side to side”
in the groove wall. But some of the first recordings were
vertically cut, also named as ”hill and dale” recordings.
Because of that, a mono cartridge is not able to reproduce a
vertical groove signal. But a stereo record is a combination of
a lateral cut and a vertical cut record. Thats why you can use a
stereo cartridge. You will get the best result with a special
costum made stylus for this purpose.
Ask your ”Cartridge Man” for purchasing the right stylus.
For reproduction of Pathé and Edison vertically cut records,
activate the ”VERTICAL” switch.
Further references:
International Association of Sound and Audiovisual Archives
http://www.iasa-web.org/
http://www.aes.org/
http://www.arsc-audio.org/
http://www.ebu.ch/en/index.php
http://www.archivists.org/
http://www2.grammy.com/GRAMMY_Foundation/Grants/
Power requirements:
Frequency response: 18 Hz to 54 kHz (-1 dB)
Input impedance: 47 kOhm/220 pF (MM), 50/100/200 Ohm (MC)
Gain @ 1KHz: 50dB (MM), 75dB (MC)
Max out: +24 dBu
Output impedance (normal out) 50 Ohm
Load impedance (normal out): > 600 Ohm
Deviation from RIAA-curve: max. 0.5 dB
Distortion @ +10dBu out (20Hz-20KHz): 0.03%
Noise: -70dBA below 2.5mV in (MM), -70dBA below 1mV in (MC)
Channel separation @ 10KHz: > 55dB
0 dBu = 0.775 V
Balanced XLRs: Pin 1 = ground, pin 2 = hot, pin 3 = cold.
Transferring of 78 RPM and
LP's - 78 RPM and
RIAA Preamp
Equipment List and Pro-audio
links - References
Price list - Danish
Homepage - Search
vadlyd.dk